Photoshop Contest PhotoshopContest.com
Creative Contests. Real Prizes. Essential Resource.
You are not logged in. Log in or Register

 
Photoshop Contest Head to Head Tournament 2011
abraham vs rockyjob
winner! votes round compare to
abraham 80 Round #7 original
Winning Image

Voting Details
VoterComment
Swarhzonov Swarhzonov
...
drybie drybie
Fantastic work. Really well done.
Rangizzz Rangizzz
Great theme and mood here, great lighting, awesome chop!
DaVinci DaVinci
Nice one!
ShootHerman ShootHerman
...
deshone deshone
nice !
Grefix Grefix
Style reminds me of the Samorost games from Amanita Design ( http://amanita-design.net/games.html )
captainSMITTY11 captainSMITTY11
simply cleaner...gets my vote
billtvshow billtvshow
Both are pretty solid. I'm guessing the other is a tornado since stuff is getting sucked into it. The transition between the edge of it and the untouched part seems a bit abrupt, as if there needed to be more dust and debris being spun out beyond the confines of the cloud. On this one, I'm loving the source usage in the foliage and the building manip is solid. Weird bit of extreme blurriness in the lower left shadows, but not enough to sway me from voting for it.
Heinlein Heinlein
...
Sliver Sliver
...
koorio koorio
Great
Tommeken Tommeken
...
Tad Tad
...
Gort Gort
...
Krank Krank
...
tadams tadams
Very nice work on both entries. The flying birds don't look right (distance/closeness) and and grab too much attention.
Takser3 Takser3
...
rockyjob rockyjob
Fantastic Abe! Best of luck next round! :D
the202 the202
...
anfa anfa
...
Totoy Totoy
hanip!
Patre Patre
...
NButler NButler
...
jasper jasper
...
betdoval betdoval
:)
EJH EJH
...
Sh!Za Sh!Za
#like this beautiful silence!
anabe anabe
spectacular, great light reflections, mood, fantastic job!
Ammorio Ammorio
...
thbeghin thbeghin
:)
Goat1981 Goat1981
Great work, both. Lots of effort on other image, but this, to me, is more aesthetically pleasing. Great manipulation, nice composition, and crisp. ;)
Eve Eve
Good job on both.
bud1121 bud1121
beautiful work
vokaris vokaris
Nice
TheShaman TheShaman
...
Cartoon Contractor Cartoon Contractor
...
Tea Man Tea Man
...
supak0ma supak0ma
excellentastic
Martrex Martrex
As usual tough choices, I like this one more because to me it has a calming feel. ; )
bogsy bogsy
...
Granulated Granulated
Delicious.
Trann Trann
The elements of the other don't fit all that well but I get the intent. This, however, gets my vote.
JORDAN792 JORDAN792
very hard to choose! this takes the cake though. congrats to both of you
Michel Michel
Like this one better.
dsclink dsclink
Both good images, difficult choice. No criticism of the other, but this one gets the edge for being a bit more 'artistic'.
Dream_weaver Dream_weaver
...
Napalm32 Napalm32
...
Synthvet Synthvet
...
MikeDascola MikeDascola
...
Tawiskaro Tawiskaro
Both very interesting images, but this one wins for me. The other has a story and some strong components, but I think the lighting isn't quite right. This one is a bit stronger.
rose-wood71 rose-wood71
...
Zetape Zetape
...
TJ TJ
Not hot on the birds, but this gets my vote.
UntExp UntExp
...
bigbuck bigbuck
...
edovan edovan
...
tdiddy tdiddy
...
Pearcinator Pearcinator
This one looks great! The other is alright but the dog in the foreground looks too blurry and that's the 1st thing i notice when i look at the chop
Hagen Hagen
Even though all the pieces are not well integrated together (foreground and background especially), I'll go for this one and hope that you'll do better in the final...! The thing that bothers me in the other chop is the three weird lines in the dust cloud...! I assume they are meant to be water running down the camera lens but in my opinion they do not do any good to the chop... Anyway to good efforts...! +1
YerPalAl YerPalAl
Both are great, but . . . . .
Salvezza Salvezza
very nice..
blue_lurker blue_lurker
What can I say that has not been said by those before me cept...well done to you both
Dechene Dechene
...
ReinMan ReinMan
Hard to choose between these two images... the other entry seems to have more source but, to my eyes, doesn't seem "glued" together so well. This one is a beautiful image, on a few levels . . . so I'll go with it.
ElectronChaser ElectronChaser
Very nice.
L@rue L@rue
...
JAM JAM
...
cafn8d cafn8d
Congrats and well done to both of you! In other, the water bits, and particularly the droplets (which I thought were oddly lit stones at first) are confusing to my eye, and hurt the image a lot, although I love the added touch of the fleeing dog and children instead of adults. This one is a solid image, good manipulation and lighting, and all-around a better execution.
pakimo pakimo
...
sonic3 sonic3
Again two really great entries, hard to choose. I feel the dog hurts the other a little, but on this one i cant find anything i dont like. Well done to both :)
Mir Mir
both are good but this one seems a little bit better, well done both of you.
Claf Claf
I prefer this one. Very aesthetic, nice ambiance & light, it looks very good! Crisp & nice details! But I feel it is not a very original composition... I feel I saw too often this kind of image. I would have liked to see more from the source. But great job! Some nice details on the other chop, but needs some adjustments. The contrast between the very sunny foreground with crisp shadows and the dark & dramatic background is maybe problematic. Some details in the dirt are confusing, the kids look like happy when I figure they are supposed to freaking out... but nice touch with the water drops, well done! Congrats for a great semi-final match! :-)
Buszjegy Buszjegy
...
Ivan Roujev Ivan Roujev
...
nifft nifft
...
pjsev pjsev
Nice Image! :)
ScionShade ScionShade
...
KENNY CHUNG KENNY CHUNG
...
bogonet bogonet
Great performance both of you. I choose peaceful mood this time.


author votes round compare to
rockyjob 18 Round #7 original

Voting Details
VoterComment
abraham abraham
Wow, nice theme and well done, good luck!
gsenthil gsenthil
Tesore Tesore
Both fantastic. I'll go for The anger of the volcano.
seelcraft seelcraft
Good story!
nat_g31 nat_g31
Actually a very tough decision. I love elements of both and some things about both make me cringe. The other image had that initial wow factor but the birds in the sky look unrealistic and kill the image for me. The brids should be smaller and lower in opacity imo. This image looks nice and I love castastophic chops, so fun to put together! The flying bricks don't look right but everything else is pretty spot on! Congrats to both of you, I am a fan of you both!
jcfreak6363 jcfreak6363
VERY hard decision. Both AWESOME but like this one best.
charliesou charliesou
nevet nevet
hehe flying sheep... and a great chop too :)
gramps gramps
This is good, nice use of source. The other is a beautiful picture, but source image is scarce.
Chopper Chopper
the burning couch the burning couch
The other is well executed but the half-handed birds kinda killed it for me. I like the drama in this much more*!
annajon annajon
drama vote
buglover buglover
I go for the action. two great chops. good luck
glennhanna glennhanna
The other is visually superb, and will probably move on. It's one thing to take a scene and make another pretty painted scene with the source, but it's a whole different ball game when you get your hands dirty and introduce chaos of the mind and make the scene bleed the blood of a beast brought to life from imagination. This gets my creative thinking vote. I already spent my birds in the pretty sky vote on Rangizzz's entry.
bsoholic bsoholic
metalic metalic
roger1 roger1
meldinar meldinar


« Go to previous match - back to tournament
Navigate PSC
Contests active  archives  winners  prizes  sponsors  events  rules  rss 
Galleries votes  authentic  skillful  funny  creative  theme  winners 
Interact register  log in/out  forum  chat  user lookup  contact 
Stats monthly leaders  hall of fame  record holders 
PSC advantage  news  (rss)  faq  about  links  contact  home 
Help faq  search  new users  tutorials  contact  password 

Adobe, the Adobe logo, Adobe Photoshop, Creative Suite and Illustrator are registered trademarks of Adobe Systems Incorporated.
Text and images copyright � 2000-2024 Photoshop Contest. All rights reserved.
A venture of ExpertRating.com

PSC Time 8:17 pm EST